Email Sign-Up Go to Shopping Cart (0)
 
 

Notice about our Updated Privacy Policy »
EVERYDAY LOW PRICES ON PET SUPPLIES - 100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE - FREE SHIPPING on orders $49 or more*
Helpful Links:
Email Sign Up »
FREE Catalogs »
Gift Certificates »
Flea & Tick Control »
Prescription Heartgard »
Feeding for the Cure »


Shop Toys
Nontoxic Toy
32 results
x

Best Ball Toy

As low as $27.99
These tough balls truly live up to their name! Your horse will exhaust himself kicking, rolling, and chasing this ball throughout the stable or pasture. A great way to relieve boredom and stress. Made of hard, nontoxic polyethylene that resists punctures due to bites, stomps, or kicks. Plus, it doesn't need air and won't deflate. Choose 10" or 14" diameter. ...
View More
x

Can Toy for Dogs

As low as $9.99
Natural rubber dog toy is easy on pet teeth and gums Sustainable, nontoxic and biodegradable Openings on ends are great for stuffing with treats Entertain your dog with a natural rubber treat toy that's easy on the teeth and gums. Can Toy resembles a soda can. The real thing is attractive to dogs, but also dangerous. This natural rubber version ...
View More
x

Tug-N-Toss™ Mini by Jolly Pets

SAVE!
As low as $4.49
Treat-dispensing toy offers tugging, fetching, bouncing, and treat-seeking fun. Made of nontoxic rubber, Tug-N-Toss features an easy-to-grip handle at the top, so it's easy for dogs to pick up. You can hold the rounded end and play tug with your pet. Tug-N-Toss is also a great way to reward your pet with a delicious treat. The bottom features a small ...
View More
x

Ringbal, Tennisbal, Dogbal & Bonbal by petprojekt™

SAVE!
As low as $4.99
Natural rubber dog toys offer safe, nontoxic interactive play Each of these balls features a unique design for tossing, fetching fun Free of BPA, phthalates, cadmium and lead Ball toys have never been more fun, thanks to unique designs that boost interactive play. These natural rubber toys by petprojekt are safe and nontoxic. Some of the designs allow you to ...
View More
x

Jolly Apple Horse Toy

As low as $7.99
Apple-scented toy entertains stabled horses Redirects destructive chewing behavior Made from puncture-resistant plastic End your horse's stall boredom with this shiny red, larger-than-life apple toy. Conveniently hangs from ceiling in horse's stall. Helps redirect destructive chewing behavior. Horses are drawn to the delicious apple scent. Made from highly durable, nontoxic plastic. Measures ...
View More
x

Cataction Feather Tail Catnip 3-pk Toys for Cats

SAVE!
As low as $5.19
Feather tail toys bring out your cat's inner hunter Rubber toys in "prey-like" shapes offer satisfying chewing action Infused with high-quality catnip oils for irresistible appeal These rubber cat toys boast feather and streamer tails to kick start kitty's hunting fun. They are also infused with high quality, USA-made catnip oils to keep her interest. Bodies in fish, mouse and ...
View More
x

KONG Squeezz Toys

As low as $3.99
Squeezz toys produce erratic bounce for hours of fun Durable, nontoxic toys come in multiple shapes and sizes for any dog Protected, recessed squeaker offers an irresistible response to chewing Let your dog enjoy a durable KONG Squeezz toy indoors or out. The erratic bounce of these toys makes fetching, tugging and squeezing much more entertaining and rewarding. These vibrant-colored ...
View More
x

Dogring™ and Dogstik™ Toys by Pet Projekt

SAVE!
As low as $3.99
Tossing and fetching fun is safer than ever with these soft-grip 100% natural rubber toys. Pet Projekt dog toys are made from safe, nontoxic rubber in shapes that are easy for dogs to carry and easy for you to throw. Each promotes healthy, interactive play between you and your pet. Dogring is a super-flexible disc-shaped flyer with open center. Dogstik ...
View More
x

Orka Cat Wiggle Worm Toys

As low as $3.99
Catnip-infused cat toy gives your chewing cat a great chewing outletFloppy, wiggly toy your cat can carry, bat, and pounceUnique bumpy texture helps massage gums and promotes dental health Give your chewing cat an exceptional and interactive play experience that just may stop him from chewing on inappropriate objects. Wiggly cat chew toy has a floppy shape that adds movement ...
View More
x

Kyjen Puzzle Toys for Dogs

As low as $9.99
Easily stimulate your treat-motivated dog's intellect. Challenging puzzle toys keep him busy and out of trouble, and offer a reward to keep him interested and entertained. Try all 4 to change up the challenge and bring new excitement. Teach your dog how to retrieve the treats, and then show off his smarts every time you have a visitor. Nontoxic, dishwasher-safe ...
View More
x

Busy Buddy Squeak 'n Treat Toys

As low as $10.99
Enjoy double the fun with a toy that functions as both a treat dispenser and a squeaker. Made from natural vanilla-scented rubber, these nontoxic toys offer Treat Meter prongs to slowly dispense small kibble or treats (sold separately). The other side of the toy has a built-in squeaker to tease and taunt your pet's every chomp. Gives you the squeaker-toy ...
View More
x

Petstages Mini Toys for Small Dogs

As low as $3.99
Toys with purpose made especially for small dogs Interactive toys ideal for helping your dog burn off excess energy Stuffing-free toys are safely made and leave no stuffing messes Your small dog likes to burn off energy, too, so provide toys made just for small breeds with Petstages Mini Toys. Mini Bone Tug is ideal for a game of toss ...
View More
x

Tretkon™ and Bumpi™ Dog Toys

SAVE!
As low as $4.89
100% natural rubber toys are safe and nontoxic for pets Fun, treat-holding toys are great for engaging boredom-busting activity Toys contain no phthalates, BPA, cadmium or lead Encourage healthy foraging behavior with a 100% rubber treat toy. Simply place small treats or kibble in these toys, give them a roll on the floor and watch your dog work to retrieve ...
View More
x

Celebration Toys

As low as $7.99
Colorful bird toys with chewable paper sticks Festive toys provide a healthy outlet for natural bird behavior Encourages foraging and preening activities Brightly colored wood and paper toys turn playtime into party time. Each eye-catching toy includes chewable, pullable paper sticks firmly anchored in a vibrant wood block. Double the preening fun with the Whiskers Bird Toy which features ...
View More
x

Gripper Balls

As low as $11.99
Soft vinyl squeaky toy perfect for dogs who love to tote their toys Easy-to-grab ball keeps your dog batting, shaking, fetching, and chasing Dog ball makes a great toy for playtime anywhere - indoors or out Treat your dog to a ball he can carry around with ease! Soft vinyl squeaky ball encourages batting, shaking, fetching, and chasing indoors and ...
View More
x

Nylabone Puppy Ring Bone

As low as $4.49
The Puppy Ring Bone is specifically designed for teething puppies to satisfy the natural urge to chew and encourage the development of non-destructive chewing habits. Made from soft, nontoxic nylon infused with yummy chicken flavor. The Puppy Ring Bone also features raised ridges and nubs to help clean teeth as your puppy chews. The Puppy Ring Bone is not recommended ...
View More
x

Nylabone Double Action Puppy Chew

As low as $5.29
Chew toy for teething puppies satisfies natural chewing urges, encourages non-destructive chewing habits Soft, nontoxic rubber PLUS hard rubber enhancements for texture variation and teeth-cleaning benefits Infused with bacon flavor to add tempting taste to each chew session The Double Action Puppy Chew from Nylabone is specifically designed for teething puppies to satisfy the natural urge to ...
View More
x

Nylabone PuppyBone

As low as $6.39
The PuppyBone is specifically designed for teething puppies to satisfy the natural urge to chew and encourage the development of non-destructive chewing habits. As your puppy chews, bristles raise from the PuppyBone to help clean teeth and massage gums. Made from soft, nontoxic nylon infused with yummy chicken flavor. The PuppyBone is not recommended for dogs with any adult teeth. ...
View More
x

Paw-zzle Balls

As low as $9.99
Two-balls-in-one means pure delight for your ball-loving dog! This interactive, puzzling dog toy rolls unpredictably and invites your dog to try to remove the center ball from the larger outer ball. But try as he might, your dog won't be able to remove the inner ball from Paw-zzle Balls' 5 just-too-small holes. The Paw-zzle Ball is sure to keep your ...
View More
x

Nylabone Puppy Teething Keys

As low as $4.69
Nylabone's Puppy Teething Keys chew toy is specifically designed for teething puppies. Satisfies your puppy's natural urge to chew and encourages the development of non-destructive chewing habits. As your puppy chews, the Puppy Teething Keys help clean teeth and massage gums. Made from soft, nontoxic nylon. The Puppy Teething Keys chew toy is not recommended for power chewers or dogs ...
View More
x

American Glow Ball

SAVE!
As low as $3.99
Glows in the dark for pets that love to play when the lights go out Expose it to the light for just a few minutes to activate the glow Soft mouth feel but yet super durable soft-flex material Offer a midnight ball chase when you play with a glow-in-the-dark ball toy for dogs. American Glow Ball is charged and activated ...
View More
x

Nylabone Puppy Stix

As low as $3.99
Chew toy for teething puppies satisfies natural chewing urges and encourages non-destructive chewing habits Raised bristles help clean teeth as your puppy gnaws on this fun chew toy Soft, nontoxic nylon chew toy perfect for puppies Nylabone's Puppy Stix chew toy is specifically designed for teething puppies. Satisfies your puppy's natural urge to chew and encourages the development of ...
View More
x

Nylabone Puppy Teething Pacifier

As low as $4.69
Nylabone's Puppy Teething Pacifier chew toy is specifically designed for teething puppies. Satisfies your puppy's natural urge to chew and encourages the development of non-destructive chewing habits. The Puppy Teething Pacifier also helps clean teeth and massage gums as your puppy chews. Made from soft, nontoxic nylon. The Puppy Teething Pacifier chew toy is not recommended for dogs with any ...
View More
x

Stuff n' Throw Ball and Stuff n' Crunch Treats

SAVE!
As low as $7.19
Nontoxic interactive chew toy is made super tough to LAST Treat pockets can be filled with Stuff n' Crunch treats for rewarding fun This ball floats for water fun - it's also dishwasher safe and recyclable Stuff n' Throw Ball toy ensures hours of treat-retrieving fun. Its flexible, nontoxic composition is easy on dog's teeth and gums, yet super tough ...
View More
x

Nylabone Double Action Chew

As low as $10.99
Strong chew toy for dogs features a minty fresh center to freshen breath and tasty bacon flavored ends Raised dental nubs massage gums while helping to control tartar and clean teeth Durable ends outlast even the biggest bites Tough dental action for the toughest of chewers. EZ Carry, minty fresh center attacks bad breath, while dental nubs on durable ends ...
View More
x

Mini Activity Wall by Super Bird

As low as $9.99
Mini Activity Wall delights your curious bird with different climbing levels, natural textures, and color variety. Watch your bird climb the natural seagrass frame while pecking and chewing at the attached toys. Mini Activity Wall is made of seagrass, vine chains, plastic toy pieces, and shoelace. This multitude of textures extends your bird's playtime entertainment and shredding ...
View More
x

Activity Wall by Super Bird

As low as $12.99
Fun-to-chew seagrass grid is a launching pad for your bird's playtime shenanigans. Watch her climb the various seagrass rungs and chew the multitude of textures, all while enjoying the variety of visually stimulating colors. Activity Wall is made of seagrass, vine chains, paper donuts, wood and plastic toy pieces, and shoelace. This toy is sure to extend your bird's playtime ...
View More
x

Waffle Stuffers 3-Pack

As low as $4.99
Waffle Stuffers' unique design makes them great for tucking in any number of your bird's favorite small treats and toys. They arrive at your home pre-loaded with tempting crinkle shredding paper to engage your bird's foraging instincts. They can be used as toy pieces for making your own bird toys or as foot toys for larger birds. After the included ...
View More
x

Petstages Orka Dog Toys for Power Chewers

As low as $6.99
Fun chew toys with raised textures for dogs that love to chew Provide dogs an appropriate and durable outlet for chewing Raised textures massage your dog's gums while rope removes soft tartar Keep power chewers productively occupied while supporting overall oral health. Petstages Orka Dog Toys for Power Chewers provides a fun, appropriate chew outlet for dogs of all ages ...
View More
x

Dura-Squeaks Dog Toys

As low as $3.69
Durable toys ideal for dog fetching, tugging and squeaker fun Great for medium to aggressive chews Safe and gentle on dogs' teeth and gums Unique neon dog toys offer energetic, erratic bounce sure to make fetching and tugging more fun. Each is made from a super-durable, nontoxic material that bounces, squeaks, floats and is easy on dogs' teeth and gums. ...
View More
x

Soft-Flex AirBall Dog Toys

As low as $3.99
Heavy-duty, nontoxic vinyl dog toys great for retrieving, toting, and squeaking These toys for dogs fly further, bounce higher, and make fetch more FUN! Puncture-resistant dog toys have a molded-in squeaker for irresistible sound Heavy-duty, nontoxic vinyl AirBall dog toys are perfect for retrieving, toting, and squeaking. With aerodynamic design and tough rubber construction, AirBall toys ...
View More
x

Soft-Flex® Clutch Ball

As low as $3.99
Flexible plastic with easy-to-clutch design Tough and durable, yet soft on the mouth Built-in squeaker entices play and boosts interaction Keep your pet on the chase with these fun, fetchable ball toys. Heavy-duty, nontoxic, and flexible plastic balls boast a bumpy, textured surface that entices pets to pick up and play. Triangular nubs cause the ball to bounce erratically when ...
View More
 



Contact us